In the Bag: What’s the best way to pack groceries?

By Sean Vale, Photos by Karen Ducey

This article was originally published in November 2022

Contest winner Amanda Benson from the Green Lake Village PCC


Some guidelines are clear for the best way to bag groceries. (General rule #1: Don’t let eggs get smashed on the bottom!) Others are more nuanced. Add in the different puzzle pieces making up every shopping list and the time pressure of a long line, and it’s a real skill to pack balanced bags in a fast and friendly and food-safe way.

As a lead-in to the Best Bagger competition sponsored by the Washington Food Industry Association Educational Foundation—and as a way to have fun and honor our expert staff—each PCC location held a store-wide bagging competition earlier this year. The store winners then gathered for a co-op championship. The 22-item challenge for each contender included an avocado, a pint of hot deli soup and a replica pint of ice cream, three plums and four bananas, a bottle of wine and a glass jar of salsa, a replica whole raw chicken, hot dog buns, a 5-ounce bag of potato chips, a box of cereal, a pound of bulk split peas, a bunch of kale, a bar of soap and a round of soft Brie.

Setting the stage

The 16 competitors met at the spacious Bellevue store early one late-summer morning, the uneasy silence of the room indicating the tense anticipation of the event—or possibly that their coffee hadn’t kicked in yet. Despite the trepidation of that start, the mood was almost raucous after the first round.

The contest was organized into three rounds (plus a special surprise addition to let store directors show their stuff). To assure equal footing, all the contestants had that same 22-item assortment laid out in exactly the same way. Even the selection of bags—one paper, one reusable—was identical. Judges were Nick Novak, Bellevue’s assistant store director, Darryl Pittman, PCC’s senior director of operations, Leah Quigley, receiving and inventory program manager, and Tim Tackett, director of store operations.

baggin contest
Kiera Parnell from the Redmond PCC

Making the grade

Contestants’ scores were based on four criteria: proper building technique, distribution of weight between bags, customer experience and efficiency.

PCC staff training goes beyond some of the don’t-smash-the-eggs basics, especially when it comes to food safety (and quality) issues. Some tips that may be useful if you bag your own:

  • Proper building technique is the foundation of every good bagging experience. Place square items on the sides of the bags to help with structure.
  • The golden rule: Heavy items on the bottom, crushables on top.
  • Keep cold and hot items far apart.
  • Separate glass items so they don’t bang together.
  • Separate cleaners and scented items from food.
  • Ensure meats and seafoods aren’t at risk of dripping onto other items.
  • Slip small items into available spaces.
  • Treat soft fruit with particular care.
  • Weight distribution helps to make sure that a shopper isn’t burdened with one extremely heavy bag and one that is under-packed and too light. Canvas bags can be extra-large and it’s important not to make them too heavy.
  • Don’t snap open paper bags—it can break off the handles.
  • Communicate with customers and know their preferences (this one comes automatically if you’re bagging your own!).

While all of those more technical aspects of bagging are to be expected, the friendliness, engagement with the customer, appearance and self-confidence are also important ingredients that go toward making a great bagger. While it’s an entry-level job for some (though not all), it has outsized importance: The final interaction a shopper is likely to have with a store staff member is with the person bagging their groceries.

How well each competitor mastered each of these skills, all as efficiently as possible, determined who moved on to the next round.

apron with pins
Riley Pierce from the Burien PCC was buttoned up for the competition

Best of the best

After a great day of competing, learning new things, and getting to know each other, our competitors greeted their new champion, Amanda Benson from the Green Lake Village PCC.

As Novak described it, “Amanda was cool, calm and collected during her championship run.”

The prize was bragging rights and a reusable canvas tote packed with goodies and gift cards. (The winner would have represented PCC at the statewide bagging competition, but it was canceled this year.) Second place went to Jordan Carrasco of Green Lake Aurora, third to Riley (R.J.) Pierce from the Burien store, and fourth to Quincy Van Steenberge of the Issaquah store.

Ever the humble and gracious winner, Benson had a few tips to share with her fellow competitors and anyone wanting to up their bagging game.

“For me, it’s all about building walls,” she said. “I try to get the sturdy items on the exterior of the bags, so I build some structural support. Then other, sturdier items to fill out the middle, and crushable items on top. That’s my strategy.”

Benson’s ability to bag quickly and efficiently was key to her success, but so was keeping her cool and having fun. Say hello and congratulations if you see her or our other champions at the store.

supportive staff
John Lilley, store director at the Issaquah PCC, holds a sign behind Quincy Van Steenberge


We think all PCC’s staff members are stars in their own right, but those below are the official champions of their store bagging competitions, judged on criteria that include efficiency, customer experience, and the ability to best protect the groceries and distribute their weight between bags.  In some cases a runner-up attended the co-op competition; those names are in parenthesis.

Chloe Carlson
Alternate: (Julaine Hall)

Ali Post

Mia Barber

Linda Lamsen
Alternate: (Riley Pierce)

Central District:
Sayed Hussain

Columbia City:
Christien Roberts 

Steffan Cham 

Molly Brogan 

Laurae McIntyre (also a PCC board member)

Green Lake Aurora:
Jordan Carrasco 

Green Lake Village:
Amanda Benson 

Quincy Van Steenberge

Tony Carlson
Alternate: (Alyssa Strobele)

Kiera Parnell 

View Ridge:
Casey Smith 

West Seattle:
Meg Wickersham

Also in this issue

Harvesting skills, community—and crops—on a rare historic farm

At Marra Farm in South Park, one of the few remaining pieces of Seattle’s agricultural history, three non-profit organizations are growing a new future.

Holiday gift picks from PCC’s staff

Looking for great gift ideas? We asked PCC staff for their top picks from store shelves.

Soda tax funds support food equity programs

A tax on sweetened beverages will help 22 local programs provide nutritious, affordable and culturally relevant food to their communities.